FONT SIZE | RSS FEEDS EMAIL THIS PRINT THIS POST A COMMENT EMAIL ALERTS
View all blog entries
December 2009
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun
« Nov   Jan »
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
Monthly archives
What do liberals do on health care reform now?

We “angry liberals” are outraged at what Politico is calling President Barack Obama’s push for health care reform — any health care reform — regardless of its contents. And is it any wonder why? This bill is a compromise of a compromise of a compromise.

Despite campaign-trail promises from Obama and a more recent pledge from U.S. Sen. Harry Reid, the bill will not have a public option in it. Then, a compromise proposal that would have expanded Medicare to people as young as 55 was whittled away, after Obama Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel personally asked Reid to capitulate to the petulant U.S. Sen. Joe Lieberman, who represents insurance companies.

What’s still in the bill? A provision that requires us all to buy health insurance, which big insurance companies — not “angry liberals” — have been pushing for a long, long time. What’s not in it? A way to keep the costs of that plan under control. Natch.

Politico reports that even liberal senators who were saddened and frustrated by the vanishing of the public option may still vote for the final bill, because it’s better than nothing. But AlterNet writer Darcy Burner has a piece today that says maybe doing nothing is better than passing this soggy, watered-down, pathetic shadow of what used to be health-care reform. (We’re paraphrasing, but not by much.)

We’ve written before that Reid could only benefit by passing health-care reform with a robust public option, especially when the “2012″-like end-of-the-world predictions of Republicans failed to materialize thereafter. Ditto for Obama.

But if the current Senate proposal passes, Reid could very easily see a backlash. It was Reid who left Lieberman in the Democratic caucus, and for what? So he could obstruct them from inside their own meetings? And it’s Reid who’s considered the master of the Senate process, the ultimate back-room deal maker. For his sake, we hope Reid has one of those classic deals up his sleeve to outmaneuver Lieberman now.

Because if he doesn’t, especially for progressives (the non-Stockholm ones outside of Nevada, we mean) Reid may face the same conundrum that Burner outlines for the health-care bill: Vote for a loser, or kill the damn thing entirely.

Post a comment!
Terms & Conditions
The following comments are provided by readers and are the sole responsiblity of the authors. By publishing a comment here you agree to the comment policy. If you see a comment that violates the policy, please notify the Online staff.
4 Responses to “What do liberals do on health care reform now?”

Milly-

Of course, it’s not like Democrats are blameless here. If Obama showed more resolve, and if Reid & Pelosi showed more spine, we probably wouldn’t be where we are now. And even if all 3 of them were tougher, they’d still have to wrestle with all these Blue Dog ConservaDems that are bought and paid for by the HMOs and PhRMA.

Still, Colin has a valid point on the Republicans. With them spending every second of every day delaying the bill to the point of death (since they want to kill the bill regardless of what it really is), that just makes Reid’s job and Pelosi’s job that much harder. And with ConservaDems like Bart Stupak in the House and Joe Lieberman in the Senate constantly threatening to join the GOP in a “united front opposition”, they’re constantly in a bind.

So honestly, I think the health care mess is more complicated than either you or Colin think it is. Again, the Democrats aren’t without fault here (especially the ConservaDems!)… But it’s not like we should let the GOP completely off the hook, either.

Written by: atdleft on Thursday, Dec. 17, 2009 at 9:41 AM

Oh, come on, ColinFromLasVegas… enough with blaming the GOP. Personally, I despise nearly everything Republicans stand for. But after the Democrats won the White House and the majority in both the House and the Senate, it was time for them to roll up their sleeves and get done what they promised to do during their campaigns.

So, enough with the finger-pointing. Be a mensch and admit that the Democrats who were elected to office are caving like a sinkhole.

Milly (registered Democrat since 1980)

Written by: Milly on Thursday, Dec. 17, 2009 at 9:28 AM

Reid made a major mistake in listening to Obama and his request to show “Holy Joe” Loserman mercy. he should have just kicked out “Traitor Joe” then & there. But now, I guess we just have to fly by the seat of our pants & hope that there’s still time to save health care from the ConservaDems and GOoPers (thanks for the reminder, Colin) who want to steal it away from us.

Written by: atdleft on Wednesday, Dec. 16, 2009 at 3:21 PM

It’s so easy to point fingers at Senator Reid, Senator Lieberman, and other potential Democrats who may vote down important stuff in this health care reform bill. When any bill shows up, there are always dissenters within the ranks. It’s just natural.

But what is overlooked in this is the Grand Obstructionist Party (GOP).

The fingers don’t seem to be pointed at any RepubliCANNOTs. It should be pointed out that ANYTHING dealing with this health care reform has been met with stalling, disinformation, filibustering, organizing fearmongered teabaggers with mispelt signs and just generally no, no, no, hell no and complete and utter whining, cajoling and complaining by the Grand Opposition Party (GOP).

THEY are clearly the problem. THEY act like they are from another planet, bent on world destruction or something.

All they want is to be in power. And if thousands of Americans have to die every year because health care reform didn’t happen, it don’t make no difference to them. They could care less. They just WANT to be in power. Period. They want to call the shots. They want to go back to the excesses and idiocies of the President Bush/Vice President Cheney era. Nothing else matters. Attack. Attack. Attack. That’s all they know. Spend minimal time doing their job. Because just saying no don’t take much studying or research. But after the session is over? BAM! That’s when they are spurred into action, mad scrambles for microphones and cameras to spout out their blathering nonsense complete with no way to resolve anything to anyone that has half a brain that will listen to it.

It’s all so predictable. But it is being paid attention to. And the American voters WILL have their say in 2010 and boot most of them out on sidewalks.

As far as health care reform goes, as of right now, I’ll take anything that’s approved. Just so we can make the RepublicaNOs open their mouth wide, make them say ahhhh and shove it sideways down their throats and shut them up.

Written by: ColinFromLasVegas on Wednesday, Dec. 16, 2009 at 9:41 AM
CityPics
Community photo sharing
View reader photos and share your own at CityPics